1 April 2015

CCGs dont work as the policy documents assumed

NHS commissioning practice and health system governance: a mixed-methods realistic evaluation
Health Serv Deliv Res 2015;3(10)
  • Under the 2012 NHS reform CCGs now buy – ‘commission’ – services from NHS bodies, charities, voluntary organisations, local government and private firms. 
  • This study of CCGs in four English case studies found that in certain ways this system was not yet working as policy documents assumed. 
    • Commissioning work was often laborious and uncertain. 
    • Doctors played little part in financial negotiations with hospitals. 
    • There was little competition between hospitals, and what competition there was affected only a few aspects of hospital services. 
    • Legal controls were rarely used.
  • This report describes the convergence of commissioners’ and providers' interests across multi organisational pathways.